Australia's Selection Conundrum: Old Trafford Test

Top Online Casino And Sports Betting

With the break between the Headingley and Old Trafford Tests, the Australia selectors find themselves facing a challenging decision regarding the team’s composition. The standout performances of Mitchell Marsh and the availability of Cameron Green following his hamstring injury have created a dilemma.

Due to Green’s injury, Marsh replaced him in the third Test at Headingley and made a remarkable
impact. He scored a quickfire 118 runs and dismissed Zak Crawley twice during the match, raising
questions for the selectors.

“We have a lot to ponder and consider, as Mitch Marsh has certainly given us something to think about,” stated Australia’s head coach, Andrew McDonald.

When the Ashes squad was initially announced, national selector George Bailey hinted at the possibility of fielding both allrounders together. He expressed excitement at the prospect of fitting two or three allrounders into the top six if they were performing well with the bat.

Finding a balance that accommodates Marsh, Green, and other key players like David Warner poses a strategic challenge for the selectors. One approach could be adopting an all-pace attack, although Australia has not utilized this strategy since 2010.

As the selectors deliberate on the best combination for the Old Trafford Test, they must carefully weigh the contributions and potential of each player. The final decision will shape the team’s performance in the crucial upcoming match.

The Possibility of Marsh and Green Playing Together: Exploring the Options

Despite Mitchell Marsh’s outstanding performance in the third Test, he expressed doubts about the likelihood of him and Cameron Green featuring in the same playing XI. Marsh stated that there was unfortunately no chance for that to happen.

However, Pat Cummins acknowledged the difficulty of leaving Marsh out, considering his impressive week. Cummins mentioned the possibility of both allrounders playing together, but whether it could be implemented remained uncertain.

So, is there a way for Marsh and Green to be included in the same team? Let’s explore a few potential options:

  1. All-Pace Attack: One approach could involve fielding an all-pace attack, which would allow room for both allrounders. However, this strategy has not been utilized by Australia since 2010. 
  2. Balance in Batting Order: Another possibility is to rearrange the batting order, creating space for Marsh and Green. This would require careful consideration of the existing lineup and the roles each player would fulfill.
  3. Rotation Policy: The selectors could implement a rotation policy, allowing both allrounders to feature in different matches throughout the series. This approach would provide flexibility and rest opportunities for key players.


Ultimately, the decision lies with the Australia selectors, who will carefully assess the team’s
requirements and the impact each player can make. Finding the right balance and maximizing the potential of the squad will be crucial as they plan for the upcoming matches in the Ashes series.

Cricket blog 30 Parimatch

Contemplating the Possibility: Dropping David Warner

If the decision to drop David Warner were to materialize, it would undoubtedly be a significant moment. Warner’s struggles against Stuart Broad in the Headingley Test have raised questions about his place in the team, especially if Cameron Green’s inclusion necessitates a change in the top five batting order, as was the case with Usman Khawaja in 2019.

However, it is important to remember that it was only one game ago when Warner played a pivotal role in Australia’s triumph at Lord’s. Under challenging conditions and amidst cloudy skies, Warner showcased his value with a resilient 66 in the first innings and solid opening partnerships alongside Khawaja, setting the stage for success.

While reflecting on Warner’s contributions at Lord’s, Australia’s head coach Andrew McDonald praised his performances. However, following the loss at Headingley, McDonald stopped short of guaranteeing Warner’s place for the upcoming Test at Old Trafford. 

McDonald acknowledged the various factors that need to be considered, such as the potential inclusion of Mitchell Marsh and the team’s overall balance, including the presence of allrounders. As the Test concludes, there will be a thorough assessment of the players, including those who have demonstrated their capabilities. McDonald emphasized the need to explore available options before making a final decision.

Ultimately, the selectors will carefully weigh all these factors and make a decision that they believe will strengthen the team’s chances of success in the crucial matches ahead. 

If David Warner were to be dropped from the XI, it would create a ripple effect, potentially disrupting the team’s composition. Finding a suitable replacement to open the batting would become a pressing concern. One option could be Travis Head, who has previously filled the role in India, although the conditions there differ significantly, and Head’s presence at No. 5 is crucial to the team’s batting lineup. 

Another possibility could be promoting Marnus Labuschagne up the order. However, Labuschagne has been struggling for form recently, which raises questions about his readiness for such a responsibility. Furthermore, there are uncertainties surrounding whether Mitchell Marsh could step in as an opener, as he has done in ODIs. Andrew McDonald, when asked about this possibility, acknowledged that it hasn’t been discussed yet and emphasized that there is still time before the next Test to consider all available options.

The selectors will carefully assess the potential consequences of any changes to the batting order. It is essential to maintain stability and ensure that the team remains well-balanced as they strive for success in the upcoming matches. Ultimately, a decision will be made based on a combination of strategic considerations, player performances, and the team’s overall objectives. 

Labuschagne's Vulnerability: A Rare Occurrence

It may seem like an unusual question to ask, considering Marnus Labuschagne’s remarkable performances since his return to Test cricket during the 2019 Ashes. However, by his own lofty standards, Labuschagne is currently experiencing a relatively lean patch, with just two half-centuries in his last 21 innings.

Throughout this tour, Labuschagne has appeared slightly out of sorts. He faced a tough challenge from India’s fast bowlers in the World Test Championship final and fell to Stuart Broad’s outswinger at Edgbaston. His ill-fated slog sweep to deep midwicket at Headingley marked a turning point in the match, allowing England to regain momentum. Despite this, Labuschagne has managed to reach double figures in seven of his eight innings on the tour.

Andrew McDonald, reflecting on Labuschagne’s performances, emphasized the importance of getting solid starts. He noted that Labuschagne’s method can withstand the challenges, but there may be instances where he tries to expand his game unnecessarily. These are discussions that Labuschagne will have with himself and the coaching staff. However, the main concern arises when he fails to get those initial runs on the board.

Labuschagne’s recent dip in form should be viewed within the context of his overall success and the consistently high standards he has set for himself. While this may be a temporary phase, it highlights the importance of finding his rhythm and adapting to the specific challenges he faces in each innings. 

Cricket blog 29 Parimatch

The Absence of a Spinner: A Rare Occurrence

For the first time in 101 matches, Australia played a Test match without their renowned spinner, Nathan Lyon, at Headingley. While they managed to cope without him for most of the game at Lord’s, his replacement, Todd Murphy, had a limited impact in the third Test.

Murphy did dismiss Ben Stokes in the first innings, but he was also on the receiving end of five sixes. Significantly, he bowled just two overs during England’s chase – one before lunch and another when England needed only 30 more runs for victory.

In theory, Cameron Green could be included as an additional pace-bowling option, which would provide a lengthy batting order. However, it is highly unlikely that Australia would enter a Test match without a specialist spinner. The last time they did so was in late 2010 against England at the MCG when they relied on leg-spinner Steven Smith and part-timer Michael Clarke to handle the spin duties alongside a frontline pace attack of Ryan Harris, Peter Siddle, Mitchell Johnson, and Ben Hilfenhaus. 

Historically, Old Trafford has been known to assist spinners, with Shane Warne particularly relishing the conditions there. The pitch offers both bounce and turn. However, Lyon has only managed to take three wickets in two matches at this venue. Interestingly, since 2013, Old Trafford has recorded the secondworst bowling average for spinners among all England’s men’s Test venues. 

Head coach Andrew McDonald emphasized the importance of a balanced bowling attack that includes a spinner. It provides strategic options and prevents the team from becoming one-dimensional, relying solely on pace bowlers. While the final decision is yet to be made, the current inclination is to have a spinner in the team for the upcoming Test at Old Trafford. 

The question of whether Mitchell Marsh and Cameron Green can both feature in the same team remains a significant consideration. Another factor to ponder is that Green has not been in his best form during this tour prior to his injury. His batting average, including the World Test Championship final, stands at 19.16, while his bowling average is a relatively high 45.60. However, his fielding skills, particularly in the gully region, have made a notable impact.

It is worth noting that it is uncommon for young players to go through the early stages of their career without facing omission at some point, even if they are highly regarded talents. Hence, Green does not necessarily have to make an immediate comeback. 

Andrew McDonald, the head coach, acknowledged that finding a straightforward answer to the MarshGreen conundrum is challenging. Green’s all-round capabilities are valuable for the team’s structure, and with his full fitness for the Manchester Test, there is transparency about his availability. Nevertheless, a tough decision lies ahead for the selectors.

Recent Blogs

Cricket blog 20 Parimatch

Mehidy Hasan Unfazed by Afghanistan Loss

According to Mehidy Hasan Miraz, Bangladesh is not overly concerned about their recent ODI series defeat to Afghanistan. Despite being crushed by 142 runs and Afghanistan securing their first series win…

Cricket blog 18 Parimatch

Sri Lanka's Unblemished Record in ODI WC Qualifier

In a match that held little significance, Sri Lanka showcased their determination and talent. Despite already securing their qualification for the 2023 ODI World Cup, they displayed their relentless pursuit of..

Cricket blog 21 Parimatch

Stokes Confident in Ashes Reclaim Bid

Following their nail-biting three-wicket victory over Australia at Headingley, England captain Ben Stokes is optimistic about England’s chances of winning back the Ashes. With two consecutive losses in the first two Tests…


Advertise GIF for parimatch

Top rated online sports

Bet $5, Get $100 in Bonus Bets

Bet $5, Get $150

Bet $100, Get $100

$500 2nd Chance Bet

Bet $1, Get $200

Get $250 IN Bonus Fuds!